SCHOLAR Scholarship through Colaborative Hosting of Online Learning for Aspiring Researchers

SCHOLAR

The idea of scholarship in Teaching and Learning has remained central to the discussion about good practice in Education for many decades (Ion et al., 2022; Milner, 2020). The milieu of ideas emerged in the late 1950s and henceforth many consider scholarly praxis to be an integral part of the research-informed teaching role and context. Initially we turned to Boyer’s (1990) seminal work on scholarship. He maintained that there are four distinct while also interrelated forms or types of scholarly engagement. The first or initial idea about pure research and primary data collection places scholarly practice amidst the rigour of a Higher Education culture. He calls this the discovery phase where the practitioner in Education is observing learning through practice as a form of natural data. The second form of scholarly activity is referred to as the integration of theories and ideas from research inquiry. He posits the view that inter-disciplinary research and specialist scholarship is a powerful way of sharing with others as an interpretive type of data collection, allowing one discipline or practice to inform another. Perhaps one of the richest types of scholarship, for practitioners in Education, is the third type, the application to teaching or impact of scholarship. This involves the researcher’s (practitioner’s) focus or purpose for scholarship. Usually, practitioners work to address problems or improve practice as part of the research process. And, finally, he flies the flag for scholarship as a form of ‘conceptualisation’, suggesting the practitioner in many ways can elicit new knowledge and theories about practices, empowering them to become research informed during the process of research. It is clear that this paradigm shift, from teaching to learning and research-informed practice, is about improving or changing practices and that this evolves as a direct result of the clarity over the practitioner’s research intention and contributions to the discipline and engagement with the wider research community (Boyer et al., 2015). Moreover, researchers including Hutchings and Huber (2008), also highlight the importance of scrutiny and challenge in scholarship, accepting the validity of peer-reviewed practices and the place for such evaluations whereby scholarship becomes a process of quality improvement (Smith et al., 2024). Other practitioner researchers see scholarship as a form of naturalisation, reporting on the impact of such scrutiny on the learners and the teaching discipline or pedagogy/andragogy (Nasir, 2024). This shift away from pure research and the process of inquiry or discovery involved in evidence-based teaching and learning seems to fit with the early ideas of Boyer (1990). Based on these assertions, the project sought to combine Boyer’s classifications with insights offered by other academics on the classification, types and criterial underpinning scholarship. In particular, we drew upon Grassick et al (1997) six criteria of scholarship, each of which can be applied to discover and to teaching. These include clear goals, adequate preparation, appropriate methods, significant results, effective presentation and finally, reflective practice. Armed with this expansive tool-kit of perspectives on scholarship, this project began with the premise that scholarship is at the heart of both professional teacher education and evidence-based practices (Petty, 2020). However, we acknowledge that the phenomena of scholarship can all too often be misunderstood or misrepresented as something for the elite practitioner in Higher Education. We argue that scholarship is core to the professional practice of teacher educators and in particular, the wider teaching profession. Consequently, we posit the view that embracing the insights offered by Boyer and more recent academics indicated above, foreground engagement in practice-based experiences and associated research, is an essential component of teacher education and teacher professional learning and practice. The partners involved in this project and their respective institutions, North and South of Ireland, engage in and support teacher professional learning in their undergraduate and postgraduate programmes. The aim of the project was to support teachers and final year student teachers, undertaking a Master’s degree with exposure to and opportunities to engage with scholarship, by providing a targeted learning opportunity, in the form of a webinar. The idea behind this, was to create an opportunity to engage with experts in the field of education, with their peers who had undertaken field research or research on practice, to consult and debate the importance of teacher research and of scholarship. Subsequent to this online event and sharing of learning, the project team gathered data from participants, those taking part in the event, using an online questionnaire and subsequent focus groups, and using an observation schedule from the three researchers involved during the event. The purpose of this was to evaluate the learning experience of the participants, to explore the components of the event that had the most impact for participants, to explore the relationship between such an event and the development of scholarship. Finally, the aim was to modify research modules in the programmes in both institutions based on the findings and to continue to collaborate with a view to publishing the findings in a peer reviewed journal. The cross-border shared learning experience of planning and hosting an online conference, collaborating on the research design and write up, was fundamental to the project rationale and provided a professional space for the development of a professional narrative around the topic of scholarship, while sharing in scholarly experiences. The lead researchers from Stranmillis University College and Atlantic Technological University, St. Angelas, worked together to develop a teacher education continual professional development experience/event, in order to study the impact of scholarly activities on the teacher research journey. Staff and students from both institutions were invited to the event consisting of a keynote address from Professor John Hattie, a leading expert in educational research, and a series of peerpaper presentations from graduates of Master programmes in both institutions. A total of 65 students and 29 staff attended but data was gathered from students only. Observations were conducted during the conference by the three researchers using a self-designed observation schedule, noting contributions by participants. An online survey was sent to the participants with a response rate of 74%, and two focus group sessions were held, with teachers from both Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland teachers and student teachers (8 participants in total). The findings indicated that there was a clear link between the attendees’ exposures to scholarship and expertise and an enhanced willingness to critically engage and discuss topics within the student teacher and teacher population. In addition, the findings demonstrated the value of shared learning and cross-border mutuality [including global education] in terms of a citizenship approach to learning and an appreciation of the socially constructed elements of the subject matter (scholarship, research methodology and research paradigms). Perhaps most surprising however was the overarching acceptance by all participants, that critical thinking and metacognition was realised particularly from their participation and the interconnected learning experience itself. Participants reported many big messages that they observed and embraced in support of radical elements of scholarly thinking. They reported on facets of the career long journey of the teacher-researcher, demonstrating how they felt they had an important duty as practitioner-researchers and interpretivists in educational research, as well as seeing themselves now as influencers and leaders in research, as they venture further on their career path. The participants reported a clear alignment between scholarship and research practices. Those who presented indicated a willingness to disseminate their work further and, the attendees indicated that exposure to the research carried out by their peers and the keynote speaker/expert, meant they would consider expanding their research topics going forward and consider presenting at conferences themselves in the future. The findings are listed below: 1. Scholars learn from scholars when it is an immersive, constructivist learning experience embedded in teacher education good practice; 2. Scholarship is about conceptualisation for postgraduate and in-service professionals. Theoretical exploration and reflective practice must be built into such practices in order to support professional learners if it is to inform teaching and learning; 3. Building a community of practice in support of research programmes is an essential part of professional scholarship and teacher development. This is fundamental to the need for an aligned teacher education Master’s professional journey; 4. Purposeful learning is essential when promoting scholarly activities for professional development. Teachers must have a firm reason for learning from natural forms of data and shared education. There must be intrinsic motivation however the promotion of shared purpose during such activities can also act as a conduit for professional learning; 5. Scholarship for teachers should be motivated by impact and the realisation that best practices in teaching and learning may be achieved through the process of quality research. University level teacher education provision is pivotal in this process.